Nutraceuticals and nootropics for anti-aging
Join us on our blogs!
Dr. Alexis Zarkov:
Reinventing the Fountain of Youth and
The Delano Report:
Enhancement Methods for Bodies and Minds
Subscribe to email news from Dr. Zarkov:
You can unsubscribe at any time.
DIRECTORY
Ask Dr. Zarkov
|
|
To write this article I made notes on what is known about the causes of psoriasis and then looked for supplements that might interfere with these causes. In a few cases the supplements have been studied for their effects on similar ailments, but in most cases they have not. This article only provides a summary of some of the relevant information available on the Internet and in medical libraries. How you decide to use the information is your responsibility — I am not urging you either to self-experiment or not to self-experiment. If you decide to try any of these supplements as psoriasis treatments, you should bear in mind that you may be charting new territory and should be on the alert for side effects. Psoriasis overviewReaders unfamiliar with psoriasis may find this overview useful. Psoriasis is a disorder of the skin and nails, characterized by inflammation and abnormal reproduction of skin cells. It can also affect joints and other tissues. The disease produces areas of thickened, scaly, silvery-white and reddened skin; discolored, crumbling, deformed, or uplifted nails; and arthritic symptoms in joints. Approximately 2-3% of the population develop psoriasis. Two types of psoriasis are recognized: Type 1 strikes before age 40 and is generally found in other family members, type 2 strikes after age 40. At present there is no cure for psoriasis, but patients typically experience periods of exacerbation and remission. A common attitude among non-sufferers of psoriasis is that it is a ‘merely cosmetic’ condition and therefore not worth spending research funds on. The truth is that the cosmetic aspects alone are serious enough to drive some patients to suicide, and the arthritic aspects can be debilitating. Furthermore, research into psoriasis adds to our basic understanding of molecular and cell biology, which inevitably improves our understanding of other ailments. The causes of psoriasisPsoriasis is only partly understood. Recent research indicates that the disease is driven by activated immune cells called ‘T-cells’ (or ‘antigen-presenting cells’). These cells are involved in the recognition of foreign materials (such as viruses); when they find such a material, they communicate this information to other immune system cells by producing signalling molecules called ‘cytokines’. However, some of these cytokines can induce excessive reproduction of skin cells and cause them to develop abnormally. And some of the cytokines cause inflammation and its consequences: swelling, pain, redness, and heat. This is the essence of the disease, but the process is extremely complex and not all of the signalling molecules and growth factors involved have been identified. Important questions remain unanswered: Do genetic factors account for why some people develop psoriasis while others don’t? Why do most people get psoriasis later in life and not earlier? Does something trigger the T-cells to release inappropriate combinations of signalling molecules? If so, what is this trigger? Recent studies suggest that the microorganism Malassezia furfur may play a role in promoting psoriasis. Inflammation — the non-explanationPsoriasis and many other ailments are often attributed to ‘inflammation’. But what does this word actually mean, and is it a useful explanation for anything? Traditionally, physicians used the word ‘inflammation’ for any condition in which four characteristics were present: redness, heat, swelling, and pain. The word gave no hint of the mechanisms responsible for these characteristics, because the medical world at that time had no knowledge of molecular biology. In recent decades the molecular mechanisms involved in inflammation have been coming to light. They are extremely complicated, and involve cytokine signalling between different types of immune cells, the release of free radicals, dilation of blood vessels (which causes redness and heat), increase in permeability of capillaries (which causes swelling), and pressure on nerve endings (which causes pain). The word ‘inflammation’ is still a convenient word for this collection of processes. But it is almost useless as an explanation for anything. For example, if someone says “Psoriasis is caused by chronic inflammation in the skin,” they are telling you nearly nothing, whereas if they say “Psoriasis is caused by abnormal releases of ‘Transforming Growth Factor-alpha’ in the skin,” then they are giving you at least a partial explanation of what is going on. Treatments for psoriasisIn what follows, I will list both drugs and supplements that have anti-psoriatic properties or potential. The drugs will receive only brief mention — the main focus of this article is supplements, since they can be obtained without interference from government or medical professionals. I will give special attention to supplements that promote the body’s production of a cytokine called ‘interleukin-10’ (‘IL-10’), since IL-10 seems to hold special promise for suppressing psoriasis. Some treatments for psoriasis date back 100 years or more. These include:
These topical treatments, although beneficial in many cases, are very messy to use, and harmful if applied carelessly. They have largely been abandoned in the industrialized world, where unstained clothes are highly valued. We won’t discuss them further here. Corticosteroid drugs:
Most of these are prescription drugs that are quite effective in suppressing proriatic lesions in some people in the earlier stages of the disease. But their side effects can be serious, and include thinning of the skin, dilated blood vessels, bruising, and skin color changes. Anti-inflammatories:
Aspirin and NSAIDs are of more use in treating psoriatic arthritis than in treating psoriatic skin lesions. Antibodies and fusion proteins can prevent progression of joint destruction, but are very expensive. Since they are officially (and arbitrarily) classified as ‘drugs’ rather than ‘supplements’, we won’t deal further with these substances here. Immune-suppressive drugs:
These prescription drugs are used for severe and recalcitrant psoriasis. They require careful monitoring and can expose patients to increased risk of infections. Retinoid drugs:
Retinoids are substances that regulate the development of cells into specific cell-types, and that have anti-inflammatory activity. The doses of vitamin A required for anti-psoriatic effects are very high and cause unacceptable side effects. The other retinoids in the above list have been used with some success in treating psoriasis, but since these are prescription drugs, not supplements, they are outside of the scope of this article. Estrogens:Estrogens suppress inflammation, increase IL-10, enhance collagen synthesis, maintain skin moisture, and accelerate cutaneous wound healing by regulating the production of growth factors. It has therefore been suggested that estrogens might have value as psoriasis treatments. On the other hand, there is evidence that estrogens can exacerbate psoriasis. In the absence of clinical trials to determine the truth of the matter, the issue is unresolved. Vitamin D compounds:
Vitamin D3 and its analogs are steroid hormones that have complex effects on the mix of cytokines produced by target cells. Some of these compounds, such as calcitriol, are stimulators of IL-10 production and suppressors of inflammatory cytokines; these are therefore potential treatments for psoriasis. They will be dealt with later in this article. Calcipotriene is a ‘designer’ form of vitamin D — it is therefore a drug rather than a supplement. This substance has also been shown to increase IL-10 production. A clinical trial in 1998 showed its efficacy as a psoriasis treatment. Antioxidants:
Unusually high levels of oxidants and insufficient antioxidant activity have been found in psoriatic lesions, suggesting that excessive free radical activity might play a role in causing and maintaining the lesions, and that antioxidants might ameliorate this condition. The search for appropriate antioxidants, however, is complicated by the fact that antioxidants are cell-specific in their actions — a given antioxidant may cause the production of different sets of cytokines in different cell types, and these cytokines will then have differing effects on the production of growth factors and therefore on cell growth. For example, the green tea antioxidant ‘EGCG’ promotes the production of the cytokine IL-10 in white blood cells, but inhibits IL-10 production in certain skin cells. Whether the net effect of such an antioxidant would be beneficial or counterproductive can only be determined by clinical studies. Unfortunately, only a handful of clinical studies have tested antioxidants as psoriasis treatments. The above list of antioxidants is therefore offered merely on general principles as potential psoriasis therapies. Cell-growth inhibitors:
Since psoriasis is characterized by abnormally fast reproduction and growth of skin cells, cell growth inhibitors are naturally of interest as treatments. Furthermore, psoriatic tissue seems to require excessive growth of capillaries and small blood vessels; inhibitors of blood vessel growth (‘angiogenesis inhibitors’) are therefore also of interest. The above list includes only a few of the many plant-derived cell growth inhibitors that have been revealed by tissue culture experiments. A few of them have been tested in vivo. The best studied of these cell-growth inhibitors are resveratrol, green tea catechins, and curcumin. All three of these substances have problems, however. Resveratrol is easily degraded by air, light, and temperature, and most of the resveratrol supplements on the market are of poor quality by the time they reach the end-user. Green tea catechins, although anti-inflammatory in some tissues, are pro-inflammatory in others. Curcumin at high concentrations is a cell growth inhibitor, but at low concentrations it is a cell growth promoter — in cell culture experiments, at least. Since curcumin is poorly absorbed from the digestive tract, large doses may be required if it were used orally to inhibit cell growth. These problems suggest that one would more likely get good results for psoriasis if the substances were used topically rather than orally. A compounding pharmacy could make a cream or ointment containing curcumin and/or tea catechins. (If a good source of resveratrol can be identified, it could be included as well.) One should bear in mind, however, that some of these substances will stain clothes. Studies funded by a manufacturer of blueberry and bilberry extracts have shown them to be angiogenesis inhibitors. These extracts are highly colored and will undoubtedly stain clothes when used topically. Unfortunately they are very poorly absorbed when used orally; therefore, large doses are required. Omega-3 fatty acids:
Omega-3 fatty acids have immune-modulating effects that can be exploited to prevent or suppress psoriasis. These effects are brought about by modulation of the type and amount of cytokines produced by immune cells, by altering gene expression, and by lowering the ability of certain enzymes to produce inflammatory substances. The omega-3 fatty acids in fish oils — eicosapentanoic acid (EPA) and docosahexenoic acid (DHA) — appear to be much more effective than those in plants. Since these substances are sold as oils (i.e., as triglycerides) rather than as free acids, one must use them orally so that the free acids can be released by lipase enzymes in the digestive tract. Probiotics:
Probiotics contain ‘beneficial bacteria’ that have been shown to reduce inflammation for a variety of diseases. They seem to work by modifying the body’s production of certain T-cells. Avoidance therapies:
Smoking is a known promoter of psoriasis. Gluten, a substance found in wheat, oats, rye, barley, and millet, promotes psoriasis in some people — namely, those who have IgA and/or IgG antibodies to gliadin (a component of gluten). Androgens tend to promote inflammation and may exacerbate psoriatic symptoms. Other psoriasis treatments:
Salicylic acid is a widely used non-prescription treatment for many skin disorders. It acts as a softener of dead, hardened skin cells — it probably does not have any activity against the causes of psoriasis. Zinc pyrithione is an anti-fungal drug available without prescription. Microorganisms such as Malassezia furfur are known to be involved in other skin conditions such as seborrheic dermatitis, and are likely to be involved in psoriasis, as well. Although this substance is not a nutritional supplement, it appears to be an important adjunct to other psoriasis treatments. I will therefore include it in the list of promising remedies given in the Amounts section below. Melatonin levels in the blood of psoriasis patients lack the nocturnal peak that they have in non-psoriatics. Some patients therefore supplement with melatonin at bedtime. No formal clinical studies have evaluated this treatment. Skin-Cap and the blundering bureaucraciesSkin-Cap was a topical psoriasis product from Spain that took the psoriasis world by storm in the mid-1990s because of its remarkable effectiveness. The product’s manufacturer, Cheminova International, claimed that the product’s active ingredient was zinc pyrithione, but the truth was that the product also contained a corticosteroid, clobetasol propionate. Government drug agencies all over the world therefore banned Skin-Cap, thereby making it unavailable to the entire psoriasis community and infuriating many users for whom it had been the only treatment that had ever worked. It is interesting to note that several months before the disovery that Skin-Cap contained clobetasol, the distributors of Skin-Cap in the U.S. had been ordered by the Food and Drug Administration to stop selling it — not because the FDA deemed it dangerous or ineffective, but because it was being sold to treat psoriasis and other skin disorders. A psoriasis product that ostensibly contained only zinc pyrithione, a supplement, could be sold in the U.S. only if the seller abstains from telling the buyer what it is to be used for. The fact that Skin-Cap was the most effective psoriasis treatment ever seen did not matter a whit — the FDA’s regulations are designed to keep the bureaucrats in control, not to bring effective treatments to the public. Once clobetasol was found in Skin-Cap, however, the product’s fate was sealed. It was soon banned; users were warned not to use it and were told to send their remaining Skin-Cap back to the seller at their own expense. Many refused, of course, and there is still a small amount of the product in circulation. Many newer products are being sold on the Internet claiming to be Skin-Cap. Most are zinc pyrithione without any corticosteroid, but some do contain other corticosteroids. The particular combination of ingredients in the original Skin-Cap were far more effective than any of the ingredients used separately. New concept: the interleukin-10 connectionInterleukins are the signalling molecules (‘cytokines’) that are used by white blood cells for communication. The human immune system makes use of several dozen different interleukins, each conveying different information and causing different actions on target cells. Interleukin-10 (IL-10) is a cytokine that limits or terminates inflammatory responses and helps to regulate the formation and proliferation of several kinds of immune cells, including T-cells. (Reminder: Badly regulated T-cells are considered to be leading actors on the psoriatic stage.) One of the mechanisms involved is IL-10 suppressing the production of pro-inflammatory cytokines, such as IL-1, IL-6, and IL-8. More than ten years ago researchers discovered that psoriatic skin contains significantly less IL-10 than does normal skin. This suggested that psoriasis might be treated by raising IL-10 levels in the skin. From 1998 to 2002 several clinical trials were carried out to test this concept. It was found that IL-10 therapy caused a marked regression of the lesions, decreased the incidence of relapse, and prolonged the disease-free interval. But it became apparent that this approach was impractical — Interleukin-10 is a polypeptide and is expensive to make. It would be ineffective if taken orally or used topically (i.e., as a cream or lotion) and would therefore have to be injected repeatedly into each affected area of skin. The next step should have been obvious: search for substances that can be used topically or orally and that indirectly cause a rise in IL-10 production by the cells in psoriatic skin that are under-producing it. With today’s research tools it is possible to screen thousands of chemicals simultaneously for their effects on IL-10 production — chemicals from plants, from animals, and from existing chemical archives. So… with at least three years to develop a list of good IL-10 inducers, we should by now have many clinical trials in progress testing these inducers on psoriatic patients, right? Readers will probably not be surprised to learn that no such search has been reported in the medical literature, no list has been developed, and no such clinical trials are in progress. Such is the state of medical research in today’s government-regulated world. Nevertheless, just by searching on the Internet you and I can identify a few such compounds that have turned up during research studies not necessarily directed at psoriasis. These are:
Whether green tea, and its principal active constituent EGCG, belong on this list of IL-10 promoters is debatable. In some studies, in certain cell types, EGCG promotes IL-10 production. In other studies, in other cell types, it inhibits IL-10 production. The lack of actual clinical data on the use of EGCG for treating psoriasis means that if psoriasis patients want to know what EGCG does to psoriatic lesions, they will have to try it themselves. One supplement to avoid (with respect to its effects on IL-10, that is) is
Genistein has been shown to inhibit IL-10 production. Amounts required for anti-psoriatic effectsHow much of each of the supplements discussed in this article would one have to use in order to achieve anti-psoriatic effects? Since the clinical trials that would answer this question have not been done for most of these substances, the answers I give here are just educated guesses. Furthermore, there is a significant possibility that some of these compounds, if used orally, could have harmful interactions with other substances already being used by patients. On the other hand, certain combinations of these and other substances are likely to be better treatments than the substances used by themselves; identifying these combinations, however, will require a lot of experimentation — far more than is currently being done by the medical research establishment. Generally speaking, it makes more sense to treat psoriasis by using a substance topically rather than orally, since smaller amounts of the substance are needed, and they are less likely to affect the whole body. In some cases topical use may be impractical: for example, the omega-3 oils may be too messy to use this way — but these are beneficial for the whole body in any case. Most of the substances listed below are available as oral supplements but usually not in forms that can be used topically. Topical formulations can be made by a compounding pharmacy, or even by non-professionals if they can get the active ingredients. It pays to ‘shop around’ for compounding pharmacies, since the prices charged for the same product can vary enormously.
In conclusionCertain nutritional supplements have great potential as psoriasis treatments, but have received very little attention from medical researchers. These supplements fall into several categories, which suggests the possibility of synergistic action between the substances in different categories. Although some of these supplements seem fairly expensive, their costs are miniscule compared to the costs of many prescription drugs — and many of the latter are not even especially effective. A psoriasis patient who wants to try out some of the substances mentioned in this article should realize that he or she will be operating in largely uncharted territory. While self-experimentation is the only way to get answers to questions that mainstream medicine does not want to address, it carries certain risks that should be weighed against the risks of not self-experimenting. Is it better to try an untested treatment or to leave matters as they are? One has to judge that for oneself. While government bureaucrats and physicians’ groups are all-too-willing to tell you not to do it, I’m not as arrogant as they are — I suggest that you decide for yourself. Discussion groupI’ve set up a discussion group at Yahoo Groups for those who want to exchange information, and share experiences about self-experimentation with psoriasis remedies, especially those based on supplements. The group will be lightly moderated to remove spam and prevent verbal attacks on members (‘flaming’, in other words). To join, go to http://health.groups.yahoo.com/group/psori/. If you are not already registered with Yahoo, you will be guided through the registration process (which is free). — Dr. Alexis Zarkov, Ph.D. You can contact Dr. Zarkov at AskDrZarkov@yahoo.com. Last modified 2005.Sep.13 ReferencesPsoriasis in generalTherapeutic management of psoriasis [Tutorial on psoriasis treatments] Novel biologic therapies for psoriasis. Expert Opin Biol Ther. 2004 Jun;4(6):975-87. InflammationThe inflammatory response in mild and in severe psoriasis. Br J Dermatol. 2004 May;150(5):917-28. Nutritional treatmentsNutritional approaches for psoriasis Rainforest plant helps treat psoriasis [Dithranol] RetinoidsTopical therapies for psoriasis: evidence-based review. Can Fam Physician. 2005 Apr;51:519-25. EstrogensTamoxifen-induced remission of psoriasis. J Am Acad Dermatol. 1999 Nov;41(5 Pt 2):887-9. Vitamin DUse of vitamin D in the treatment of psoriasis — a historical analysis Antioxidants[Melatonin in dermatology. Experimental and clinical aspects] Hautarzt. 1999 Jan;50(1):5-11. Plasma melatonin levels in psoriasis. Acta Derm Venereol. 1988;68(4):312-6. Oxidative stress and its role in skin disease. Antioxid Redox Signal. 2002 Aug;4(4):665-73. [Selenium nutritional status and the course of psoriasis] Pol Merkuriusz Lek. 1999 May;6(35):263-5. Antioxidant [N-acetyl cysteine] Useful For Dry Skin and Possibly Psoriasis Topical N-acetylcysteine treatment in neonatal ichthyosis. Turk J Pediatr. 2003 Jul-Sep;45(3):245-7. Pharmacological activities of curcuma longa extracts U.S. patent # 6,841,177 January 11, 2005 Cell growth inhibitorsAnti-angiogenic property of edible berries. Free Radic Res. 2002 Sep;36(9):1023-31. Fatty acidsPolyunsaturated fatty acids and inflammatory diseases. Biomed Pharmacother. 2002 Oct;56(8):388-96. Omega-3 fatty acids in inflammation and autoimmune diseases. J Am Coll Nutr. 2002 Dec;21(6):495-505. ProbioticsAvoidance therapiesCutaneous Effects of Smoking. J Cutan Med Surg. 2005 Jul 7 Salicylic acidSalicylic Acid (Topical) MedLine Plus Skin-Cap and zinc pyrithioneThe Skin-Cap story Dave's Psoriasis Info FDA WARNS CONSUMERS NOT TO USE SKIN-CAP Psoriasis patients talk about Skin-Cap Dermatologists talk about Skin-Cap Interleukin-10Interleukin-10 Therapy—Review of a New Approach Pharmacol Rev 55:241-269, 2003 Disclaimer: The information provided in this “Ask Dr. Zarkov” article contains no medical advice whatsoever — it contains ‘biological information’. Nothing in the article constitutes an effort to persuade readers to use, or not to use, this biological information as a basis for action. |
I have psoriasis patches on my face, neck, and arms. I’ve used several prescription drugs to treat them, but the results have
been disappointing and the side effects have been scary. Are there any supplements that might do a better job?
There are quite a few supplements that might do better, but very little research has been done on this subject. Moreover, due to human genetic differences, a treatment
that benefits one patient may not benefit another. The only way to find out which, if any, of these supplements will work
for you is to try them, individually or in combinations.
Nutraceuticals
and nootropics
for anti-aging
© 2005-2010 Delano Company, Inc. All rights reserved. |
|
